Bankruptcy form offers details about man who left woman to die in golf cart fall

Timothy Jacob Foxworth

The bankrupt son of a former couple in The Villages is delinquent in a fine ordered earlier this year in Sumter County Court in the death of a woman in 2017 after falling from a golf cart.

Timothy Jacob Foxworth, 39, of Wilmington, N.C. was notified earlier this month by letter from Sumter County Clerk of Court Gloria Hayward that he has not paid a $600 fine ordered this past May by Judge William Hallman. Foxworth has until Friday to pay the fine, the letter said.

A federal bankruptcy form details Foxworth’s financial situation after his life was forever changed by the death of 51-year-old Shelly Osterhout, who had been visiting her father in The Villages when she fell from a golf cart Foxworth was driving.

Shelly Osterhout

Foxworth was virtually unpunished for that act when he pleaded no contest to two misdemeanor charges in connection with the July 16, 2017 incident. He was sentenced to one year of probation and ordered to perform 50 hours of community service. 

Foxworth had been visiting his parents in the Village of Gilchrist when he met Osterhout at a bar at Brownwood Paddock Square. They left together in his parents’ golf cart from which she fell, suffering the fatal head injury. Foxworth told police he “panicked,” dragged her body into a flower bed and drove away. She was discovered by Good Samaritans who called for an ambulance. She later died at Ocala Regional Medical Center.

Last year, Foxworth filed for bankruptcy in the Eastern District of North Carolina. The bankruptcy petition reveals the following:

Timothy Jacob Foxworth has been working in the funeral planning business.

• He has assets estimated to be worth between $100,000 and $500,000 and the same amount of liabilities. 

• Foxworth indicated he earned $79,533 in 2017, the year of Osterhout’s death. He earned $77,000 in 2018. He was working in funeral planning.

• His estimated monthly income is $6,521 and his monthly expenses are $7,270.

• He owns a home with his ex-wife in Wilmington, N.C., valued at $290,300. They owe $295,124 and have a monthly mortgage payment of $1,600.

• He also listed as assets a 2015 Jeep Cherokee, which is used by his ex-wife, as well as a 2016 Chevy Impala, which he is presumably driving.

• Foxworth appears to be current on his child support obligations.

Foxworth was represented by attorney Andrew Moses, who negotiated the charges down from DUI manslaughter and hit-and-run felonies to misdemeanor charges of culpable negligence and DUI impairment. Moses relied on case law that dictated his client could not be charged with leaving the scene of an accident because there was no crash – Osterhout fell from the golf cart when Foxworth discovered he was traveling in the wrong direction and cut a sharp U-turn. Moses also ordered a voluminous report from an expert witness which supported his argument.

The deceased woman’s father wrote a letter to Judge William Hallman expressing his outrage over the sentence. Osterhout’s father alleged that the prosecutor’s office had been intimidated by the Foxworth family’s “deep pockets.”

Foxworth’s parents sold their home in The Villages months after their son’s arrest. They relocated to North Carolina.

Roger and Sheila Foxworth have sold their home in the Village of Gilchrist within months of their son’s arrest.

Roger Foxworth accompanied his son to court on the day of the sentencing.

More Headlines

Villager arrested after allegedly spraying insecticide at Village of Marsh Bend

A Villager who was suspected of illegally spraying insecticide in the Village of Marsh Bend was arrested after an altercation with an agent from the Florida Department of Agriculture.

Villagers facing potential fines for illicitly widened driveway

A Villages couple is facing potential fines over a driveway that was widened illicitly.

Photos

Snowy Egret Taking A Morning Stroll

This snowy egret was out taking a morning stroll. Thanks to Jan Betz for sharing! Share your local photos with us at https://villages-news.com/contact-us!

Eagle Nest On Multimodal Path

The eagles are starting to add material to their nest on the multimodal path between Briarwood and Walnut Grove executive golf courses. Thanks to...

Great Blue Heron On Fence In Brownwood

Check out this great blue heron spotted on a fence in Brownwood. Thanks to Richard Steiner for sharing! Share your local photos with us at https://villages-news.com/contact-us!

Letters to the Editor

The vision of The Villages has changed

A Village of Sabal Chase resident says the vision of The Villages has changed from the “friendliest hometown” to the “most crowded overgrown city.” Read her Letter to the Editor.

Business

Total Wine & More closer to popping cork on new superstore

Total Wine & More is growing closer to popping a cork on its new superstore at Lady Lake Commons.

Crime

Wildwood police seek help locating trailer stolen from Villages construction site

Wildwood Police officers are searching for bandits who stole a trailer recently from a construction site in The Villages.

Opinions

Addressing Post Office backlogs

Last week, Congressman Daniel Webster sent a letter to the U.S. Postmaster General regarding some operational changes being made without proper Congressional oversight. Webster offers an update for constituents.

Top Stories

Village of Fenney couple with $525,000 home can’t get out of driveway

A Village of Fenney couple with a $525,000 home say they can’t get out of their driveway and pleaded for help from the Community Development District 12 Board of Supervisors.

Villager arrested after allegedly spraying insecticide at Village of Marsh Bend

A Villager who was suspected of illegally spraying insecticide in the Village of Marsh Bend was arrested after an altercation with an agent from the Florida Department of Agriculture.

Villagers facing potential fines for illicitly widened driveway

A Villages couple is facing potential fines over a driveway that was widened illicitly.

Letters to the Editor

The vision of The Villages has changed

A Village of Sabal Chase resident says the vision of The Villages has changed from the “friendliest hometown” to the “most crowded overgrown city.” Read her Letter to the Editor.

Residents should have had chance to vote on apartments at Hacienda Hills

A Villager contends residents should have had a chance to vote on the idea of apartments at Hacienda Hills.

So many promises have been broken

A Village of Santo Domingo resident, in a Letter to the Editor, writes that things have changed a lot since she moved here in 2000 and so many promises have been broken.

Crime

Wildwood police seek help locating trailer stolen from Villages construction site

Wildwood Police officers are searching for bandits who stole a trailer recently from a construction site in The Villages.

Summerfield woman wanted on warrants nabbed after hiding in residence

A Summerfield woman wanted on outstanding warrants was jailed Monday after Marion County sheriff’s deputies saw her enter the back yard of a residence near the Little Lake Weir subdivision.

Villager’s grandson arrested after fleeing hospital after crashing vehicle

A Villager’s 32-year-old grandson was arrested after fleeing UF Health The Villages Hospital where he was taken by ambulance after crashing his vehicle on County Road 466.