Man arrested after leading deputy on chase a former Leesburg basketball standout

The man who is accused of striking a Marion County sheriff’s deputy with his car early Sunday morning and then fleeing from him is a former standout basketball player at Leesburg High School.

Leesburg High School basketball standout Joe Toolie III was named the 2011 Class 4A Basketball Player of the Year and was among six finalists for the Mr. Basketball Award, which goes to the state’s top high school player.

Joe Toolie III, 24, who was arrested by Lake County deputies after a sheriff’s K-9 tracked him to his house at 215 Bisby St. in Leesburg, was a 6-foot-3-inch junior point guard with an extremely promising future on the Leesburg team that won the Class 4A state championship in March 2011. He was named Class 4A Player of the Year and was among six finalists for the Mr. Basketball Award, which goes to the state’s top high school player. And he was the state tourney’s Most Valuable Player and a member of the All-Tournament team.

Joe Toolie III led Leesburg High School to a state title in 2011.

Toolie, who averaged 12.8 points and three assists per game, led the Yellow Jackets to a 28-4 record that season. He hit 66 percent of his shots in the championship game against Fort Lauderdale Cardinal Gibbons and was the true leader of the squad that brought home Leesburg High School’s first state title since 1977.

An image of 24-year-old Joe Toolie III taken from his Facebook page.

During his senior year in 2012, Leesburg fell to Miami Norland in the Class 6A finals in Lakeland. But Toolie was chosen as a repeat all-state player on the Class 6A honor squad and appeared headed for a successful college basketball career at Daytona State College.

It’s unclear if Toolie ever attended the college, but a series of arrests and jail time that followed his high school basketball career paint a much different picture for the star athlete. In Feb. 2013, he was arrested for marijuana possession and driving with a suspended or revoked license. And in April 2015, he was charged with attempted murder, armed robbery with a firearm and shooting into an occupied vehicle and held on $110,000 bond.

In January 2016, he was charged with burglary of an occupied dwelling, larceny/grand theft and criminal mischief. In June 2016, he faced multiple charges regarding possession and sale of cocaine, as well as trespassing and petit theft. And in October of that year, he was again arrested on the same charges.

This past Sunday’s early-morning incident started when Marion County sheriff’s Deputy Christopher Witte made contact with Toolie in the parking lot of the Circle K located at 13873 SE Highway 25, at the intersection with County Road 42. Witte was told by a store clerk that Toolie had been parked in front of the store for 30-45 minutes “and appeared to be unresponsive,” a sheriff’s office report states.

These are Joe Toolie III’s booking photos from the Lake County Jail. They are from: Feb. 9, 2013, April 14, 2015, Jan. 7, 2016, June 22, 2016, Oct. 20, 2016 and Oct. 14, 2018.

During the encounter, Toolie put his vehicle in reverse and fled from the mini-mart parking, striking Witte and “almost running him over,” the report says, adding that Witte initiated a pursuit that quickly led into Lake County.

During the pursuit, Toolie turned his vehicle’s lights off while reaching high speeds, causing Witte to lose sight of him. But Lake County sheriff’s deputies spotted the vehicle, attempted to conduct a traffic stop and initiated another pursuit, the report says.

Joe Toolie III poses with friends in this photo from one of his social media accounts.

Toolie eventually abandoned his vehicle and fled on foot. A short time later, after the use of a sheriffs’ K-9 to track him and Witte positively identifying Toolie as the suspect, he was brought into custody.

Before being transported to the Lake County Jail, Toolie denied on camera that he was involved in the incident. He was then charged with aggravated battery on a law enforcement officer, felony fleeing and eluding, giving a false name to a law enforcement officer, possession of cocaine with intent to sell, possession of heroin with intent to sell and possession of marijuana with intent to sell. He also was charged with violating his probation on four other drug charges and is being held on $45,500 bond, with a scheduled court appearance of Nov. 13 at 8:30 a.m.

Joe Toolie III, left, has been held in the Lake County Jail six times since February 2013.

More Headlines

Former state Rep. Marlene O’Toole connected to Villages property deed compliance case

Former state Rep. Marlene O’Toole was connected to a property deed compliance case during a public hearing Wednesday afternoon in The Villages.

AAC members were offered choice between apartments or parking garage

A three-hour meeting Wednesday of the Amenity Authority Committee revealed that members had been offered a difficult choice - an apartment complex or a parking garage at the site of the former Hacienda Hills Country Club.

Photos

Eagle Nest On Multimodal Path

The eagles are starting to add material to their nest on the multimodal path between Briarwood and Walnut Grove executive golf courses. Thanks to...

Great Blue Heron On Fence In Brownwood

Check out this great blue heron spotted on a fence in Brownwood. Thanks to Richard Steiner for sharing! Share your local photos with us at https://villages-news.com/contact-us!

Alligator Swimming At Lake Sumter Landing

Check out this alligator swimming in the water at Lake Sumter Landing. Thanks to Terry Cooper for sharing! Share your local photos with us at https://villages-news.com/contact-us!

Letters to the Editor

Are we putting the burden on schools?

A Village of Tamarind Grove resident, in a Letter to the Editor, wonders about the burden Americans are willing to put on schools and teachers.

Business

Total Wine & More closer to popping cork on new superstore

Total Wine & More is growing closer to popping a cork on its new superstore at Lady Lake Commons.

Crime

Villager’s grandson arrested after fleeing hospital after crashing vehicle

A Villager’s 32-year-old grandson was arrested after fleeing UF Health-The Villages Hospital where he was taken by ambulance after crashing his vehicle on County Road 466.

Opinions

Incumbent Sumter County commissioners lack integrity

Sumter County Commission Craig Estep responds to recent claims by the incumbents. He contends they "lack integrity."

Top Stories

10 more local COVID-19 deaths as virus continues to slam long-term care center

Ten more tri-county residents have succumbed to COVID-19 as the virus continues to plague a Villages-area long-term care center and sweep across the local area.

Former state Rep. Marlene O’Toole connected to Villages property deed compliance case

Former state Rep. Marlene O’Toole was connected to a property deed compliance case during a public hearing Wednesday afternoon in The Villages.

AAC members were offered choice between apartments or parking garage

A three-hour meeting Wednesday of the Amenity Authority Committee revealed that members had been offered a difficult choice - an apartment complex or a parking garage at the site of the former Hacienda Hills Country Club.

Letters to the Editor

Are we putting the burden on schools?

A Village of Tamarind Grove resident, in a Letter to the Editor, wonders about the burden Americans are willing to put on schools and teachers.

Is it illegal to ‘hate’?

In a Letter to the Editor, a Spruce Creek South resident wonders about the legality of “hate.”

Who is the real Oren Miller?

A Village of Hemingway resident wonders about candidate Oren Miller’s political identity. Read her Letter to the Editor.

Crime

Villager’s grandson arrested after fleeing hospital after crashing vehicle

A Villager’s 32-year-old grandson was arrested after fleeing UF Health-The Villages Hospital where he was taken by ambulance after crashing his vehicle on County Road 466.

Nasty tiff over dirty dishes inside camper lands Fruitland Park woman behind bars

A Fruitland Park woman found herself behind bars Monday night after a violent battle with her man friend after he asked her to wash dishes inside their camper.

Fruitland Park man jailed after driving home instead of stopping for deputy

A speeding Fruitland Park man was jailed early Tuesday morning after allegedly refusing to stop for a pursuing Lake County sheriff’s deputy until he reached his residence.